West Coast Mainline rail franchise 'fiasco' to cost at least £49m
Last updated at 09:32, Monday, 10 December 2012
Transport chiefs have come in for heavy criticism after it emerged taxpayers face a “significant” bill over the West Coast rail franchise fiasco.
The Department for Transport’s (DfT) running of the West Coast bidding process lacked management oversight, with some staff “confused” by the system, according to a National Audit Office (NAO) report.
The Government has already indicated that repaying bidding costs to the companies competing for the franchise is likely to land taxpayers with a bill of about £40 million.
In its report, the NAO said staff and adviser costs, legal costs and money for the two reviews set up by the Government following abandonment of the West Coast bidding amounted to £8.9m.
NAO head Amyas Morse said: “Canceling a major rail franchise competition at such a late stage is a clear sign of serious problems. The result is likely to be a significant cost to the taxpayer.”
Virgin Trains will launch an improved service on the West Coast Mainline this week following the Government’s decision to extend its franchise.
The company will continue to run trains on the London-Glasgow route until at least November 2014.
FirstGroup had been due to take over on Monday but ministers cancelled the switch in October after “unacceptable mistakes” in the franchising process came to light.
The DfT will now restart the bidding.
Commenting on the audit report, House of Commons Public Accounts chairman Margaret Hodge said: “The DfT’s handling of the West Coast franchise was a first-class fiasco.”
She went on: “It has left the Government’s entire policy on rail franchising in disarray, as a further three competitions have had to be put on hold.
“The total cost to the taxpayer of putting it right is currently unknown but is likely to be significant.”
Ms Hodge said the DfT had “blundered into this major and complex competition for one of the biggest franchises in the country without even knowing how key parts of its policy were to be implemented”.
She added that bidders were invited to tender before the department knew how it would calculate companies’ capital needs.
Ms Hodge went on: “The department’s conduct was characterised by haste, confusion and weak internal and external communication.”
Michael Roberts, chief executive of the Association of Train Operating Companies, said: “The Government needs to grip the issues that led to the cancellation of the West Coast franchise competition.”
Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin said: “The NAO has made a number of recommendations that mirror many of the findings of the Laidlaw Inquiry in terms of the work we need to do to strengthen our organisation and the structures within it.
“I am pleased to say that we are already taking swift action on this front and I believe the plans we are putting in place to ensure future franchise competitions are conducted on the basis of sound planning, the rigorous identification and oversight of risk, and the right quality assurance, will prevent a repeat of these lamentable failures.”
Carlisle MP John Stevenson said he was “delighted” that the West Coast Mainline would stay with Virgin.
First published at 09:26, Monday, 10 December 2012
Published by http://www.newsandstar.co.uk
- Cornered Barrow thief caused fracas
- Furness General midwife admits blunders which led to deaths of two babies
- Cumbria service that helps patients returning home gets extra funding
- Relief as second Cumbria climber accounted for after Nepal quake
- Cumbria mountaineer describes horrifying moment Nepal earthquake struck
- Cumbria man airlifted to hospital after ladder fall
- Signalling problems causing delays for Cumbria passengers
- Child's BMX bike stolen in Barrow
- Range Rover damaged in Broughton
- Cumbria runners set for London Marathon
- Fan-tastic celebrations for Barrow AFC: with picture gallery
- Lakes riders shine in South Cumbria time trials: with picture gallery
- Runners make dash for Dalton 10k
- South Cumbrian darter aims for world's top 64
- Barrow AFC crowned Conference North champions: with picture gallery (25 comments)
- Special day for Barrow AFC skipper
- Proud Edmo hails Barrow AFC title success: with picture gallery
- Crarey delight as Barrow Raiders run riot (3 comments)
- Holker cruise into play-offs: with picture gallery
- Furness start title defence in style: with picture gallery
- Sea cadets prepare for their Big Clean
- Big Clean at Bardsea Beach
- Nation’s tribute for five flying heroes
- Mystery lady to sell at auction for £10k
- Winning village team could get 1,500 fans
- Selling the secrets of ship technology
- Classic cars set to return
- Why the speed trap claptrap?
- TRAVEL REVIEW: Tracing granddad Bert’s footsteps in ill-fated campaign
- FOOD REVIEW: The Plough, Lupton