Coroner raises concern over 999 coding system
Last updated at 14:16, Monday, 14 May 2012
A CORONER criticised the way an emergency call, made after an elderly woman fell and broke her hip, was handled – but said it did not affect her death.
An inquest into the death of Margaret Hopkins, held on Friday , heard an ambulance triage system rated her case as low priority, because she was conscious, breathing, and her husband thought she had an arm injury.
The 85-year-old, who had Alzheimer’s, diabetes, and a history of heart problems, had actually broken her hip, and died the next day after an operation to repair it.
The inquest heard Mrs Hopkins fell in the bathroom of her home in Church Close, Lindal, on October 16 last year.
Her husband, unable to get her up, called 999.
Having been questioned by an ambulance service operator, Robert Hopkins was told a paramedic would call him back.
His son, Robert Hopkins Junior, arrived around 15 minutes later, called 999 again, and was asked more questions.
Mr Hopkins Jr said: “At that point I would have said she had two heads if it got them to send an ambulance.”
Mr Hopkins repeatedly stressed that the paramedics, when they arrived, were “wonderful”.
The inquest then heard from Angela Lee, control manager for the North West Ambulance Service, who said the total time between the first call and the ambulance arriving was 25 minutes.
She explained the original call from Mr Hopkins snr had been “coded” based on his answers, and given a risk level which called for a senior paramedic callback within an hour or an ambulance attendance within four hours.
The second call demonstrated Mrs Hopkins’ condition had worsened, due to breathing difficulties and the leg injury.
Her case was upgraded to urgent and an ambulance was there nine minutes later.
Ms Lee explained the triaging procedure was a national system approved by the Department of Health and used worldwide.
South and East Cumbria Coroner Ian Smith, summing up, said Mrs Hopkins died of acute cardiac failure due to heart disease, with the recent injury to her hip a significant contributory factor.
He accepted, on the evidence of consultant orthopaedic surgeon, Nigel Courtman, that the surgery caused heart complications, but if they had not operated, she would have died anyway.
Regarding the ambulance response, Mr Smith said: “Given that this lady was of a certain age, and she was on the floor, I would have expected a higher priority to be given.”
First published at 13:26, Monday, 14 May 2012
Published by http://www.nwemail.co.uk
Have your say
A very sad story and my sympathies are with the family for their loss.
The coding system used is flawed in that it cannot possibly cover every eventuality. The DoH impose the ambulance service response targets, often they are contradictory of experience personnel.
Make your comment
- Big crowds expected for Ulverston pageant
- Rescuers called out twice to missing walkers on Cumbria mountain
- Barrow and Furness election hopefuls clash in debates
- Barrow man jailed for striking victim with piece of wood (1 comment)
- Rural Cumbria voters are calling for support
- South Cumbria drivers caught out by traffic warden's Sunday morning blitz (3 comments)
- Cumbria runners set for London Marathon
- Landmark Barrow hotel to make way for garage forecourt (2 comments)
- Arson appeal after Barrow shop fire
- Barrow vandals target mobility scooter (1 comment)
- We give Barrow AFC fans the lowdown on Lowestoft
- Superfan’s 6,500 mile trip to see Barrow AFC
- Day of destiny for Barrow AFC
- Edmo calls on Barrow AFC to write club history
- AFC Fylde boss still believes his side can pip Barrow AFC to title
- Toal looks forward to Barrow Raiders bow
- Consistency call from Barrow Raiders boss
- RAIDERS REVIEW: Barrow Raiders need to be ruthless
- Barrow Raiders need to play as a team - Kendall
- North Lancs and Cumbria League cricket season preview
- Sea cadets prepare for their Big Clean
- Big Clean at Bardsea Beach
- Nation’s tribute for five flying heroes
- Mystery lady to sell at auction for £10k
- Winning village team could get 1,500 fans
- Selling the secrets of ship technology
- Classic cars set to return
- Why the speed trap claptrap?
- TRAVEL REVIEW: Tracing granddad Bert’s footsteps in ill-fated campaign
- FOOD REVIEW: The Plough, Lupton