‘Failings’ led to sending home of Barrow cancer sufferer
Last updated at 16:18, Monday, 23 June 2014
THE devastated partner of a Barrow man sent home from hospital with no idea he was dying of cancer says she “can’t get on with her life.”
“Significant failings” at University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust, which runs Furness General Hospital, led to terminally ill William O’Brien being discharged in 2011 – even after a junior doctor noted “worrying test results”.
The Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, which investigates complaints against hospitals, concluded that the “failing of the trust were significant” and it had “made a mistake,” after being contacted by his partner Wendy Hofmann, 74.The PHSO “partially upheld” her complaint, after discounting her claim that the mistake contributed to his death.
Miss Hofmann, of Cotswold Crescent, Barrow, has spent the last three years desperately seeking answers after losing Mr O’Brien to non-Hodgkin’s lym-phoma.
She told the Evening Mail: “I can’t get on with my life. I want to make sure this doesn’t happen to anyone else.”
Miss Hofmann is now due to meet Ann Ford, head of hospital inspection at government regulator the Care Quality Commission, next month.
Mr O’Brien, who suffered the from lung disease chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder, was rushed to FGH’s A&E department on April 26, 2011, after collapsing during a visit to a chiropodist.
He was examined by a nurse, before being sent for further tests by a junior doctor.
He was found to have a severe chest infection.
According to the ombudsman, the doctor was also “concerned” about the fact Mr O’Brien was anaemic and that he had mentioned losing weight recently.
But despite her concerns, she did not seek the advice of a senior consultant.
Although the ombudsman said there were no “absolute guidelines” for junior doctors to say whether Mr O’Brien should have been admitted as an inpatient, it would have been “good practice” to consult a more senior doctor.
Mr O’Brien’s GP at the time, Dr Craig Stangroom, also expressed concerns in a letter to Miss Hofmann that Mr O’Brien was not admitted to hospital.
The ombudsman also said: “We are also concerned that there is no evidence that a doctor spoke to Mr O’Brien about his test results and the need for urgent further investigations.”
The PHSO said its A&E advisor said asking a GP to arrange further investigations can mean that patient’s care is delayed.
The doctor did, however, write to his GP asking for a referral to be arranged.
The ombudsman said this could have delayed his treatment, although Mr O’Brien was seen by his GP two days later.
It said: “There was evidence that Mr O’Brien was seriously ill when he was seen in A&E and the doctors should have made sure Mr O’Brien had further investigations for suspected cancer as soon as possible, and that he was aware of the situation.”
Mr O’Brien died on August 22, 2011.
Miss Hofmann said: “The way he was treated was inhuman. he tried to do everything with dignity, but he was in severe pain and nobody seemed to care.”
First published at 16:07, Monday, 23 June 2014
Published by http://www.nwemail.co.uk
Have your say
I totally understand how this lady feels,my mother was diagnosed by FGH as having asthma at 72 years old,she actually had lung cancer,how can mistakes like that be made?
Make your comment
- Cumbria mountaineer describes horrifying moment Nepal earthquake struck
- Cumbria man airlifted to hospital after ladder fall
- Signalling problems causing delays for Cumbria passengers
- Child's BMX bike stolen in Barrow
- Range Rover damaged in Broughton
- Cumbria runners set for London Marathon
- Millom Rugby Union Club awarded £10,000 grant (2 comments)
- Australian children send war tributes to South Cumbria
- Barrow attack victim: 'I was left for dead'
- Rescuers called out twice to missing walkers on Cumbria mountain
- Barrow AFC crowned Conference North champions: with picture gallery (17 comments)
- Casson over the moon with Barrow AFC title success (6 comments)
- Jubilant Barrow fans speak of joy and relief
- Edmondson hails title-winning Barrow AFC
- Barrow AFC fans ready for Lowestoft title decider:with picture gallery
- We give Barrow AFC fans the lowdown on Lowestoft
- Superfan’s 6,500 mile trip to see Barrow AFC
- Day of destiny for Barrow AFC
- Edmo calls on Barrow AFC to write club history
- AFC Fylde boss still believes his side can pip Barrow AFC to title
- Sea cadets prepare for their Big Clean
- Big Clean at Bardsea Beach
- Nation’s tribute for five flying heroes
- Mystery lady to sell at auction for £10k
- Winning village team could get 1,500 fans
- Selling the secrets of ship technology
- Classic cars set to return
- Why the speed trap claptrap?
- TRAVEL REVIEW: Tracing granddad Bert’s footsteps in ill-fated campaign
- FOOD REVIEW: The Plough, Lupton