Doubts raised over nuclear subs move - Cumbria experts have say
Last updated at 14:39, Thursday, 28 August 2014
CUMBRIA is unlikely to benefit if Scottish independence results in Britain’s submarines being moved from Faslane, experts have said.
A key issue in the debate over Scottish independence is the 8,000 jobs at Faslane where the UK’s nuclear deterrent is stored.
If Scotland gains independence, the submarines would need to be moved to England as the Scottish National Party would make nuclear weapons illegal.
The issue has raised the question of where the submarines could be housed.
Dave Barlow, chairman of the Barrow branch of the Submariners’ Association, said the tidal system and available space at the docks meant Barrow could not be home to the nuclear deterrent.
He said: “You would need to have a system whereby the subs could come and go as they please.
“Faslane is in a loch so tides aren’t an issue, but in Barrow we are restricted by the tides. Even when we build a sub and she goes out on sea trials, the departure is planned with military precision because you need to have a high tide.”
Mr Barlow, who served in the Royal Navy for 16 years onboard submarines including Valiant and Sovereign, also pointed out that the nuclear licence in place at Barrow would not allow a submarine with a working nuclear reactor to return once it had left.
He added: “Even if this was to happen and a new home was needed, it’s not something that’s going to happen overnight.”
Some have suggested that the naval base at Devonport in Plymouth could be an alternative to Faslane.
However, the base is highly unlikely to pass safety clearance to house armed submarines.
There are around 166,000 people living within five kilometres of Devonport, compared with 5,200 within that distance of Faslane.
Any site in England would also need a major upgrade.
Chris Clouter, operations manager at Associated British Ports in Barrow, said: “In Barrow you wouldn’t be able to house the submarines here without some additional infrastructure and that would involve substantial investment.”
First published at 15:54, Wednesday, 27 August 2014
Published by http://www.nwemail.co.uk
Have your say
Firstly, there are 520 jobs directly reliant on Trident, not the 8k stated. Secondly, it is the Scottish NATIONAL Party, not Nationalist.
Please do some proper journalistic research before parroting political press releases.
Oh, and I'm English, living in Scotland, voting Yes to the normality of running your own country.
Make your comment
- Barrow boy’s family hits out at children’s services
- SLIDESHOW: Barrow photographers snap up awards for artistry
- Inquest into Windermere sailor's death to take place today
- Family pay tribute to father and son who died in Cumbria crash
- Much-loved Barrow family man turned into firework
- South Cumbria detectives investigate two alleged assaults
- Call for new Cumbria community safety volunteers
- Man to be identified after body found on beach
- Police appeal after man attacked by three people in Barrow back street
- Zero hour changes given mixed welcome by Barrow firms
- RAIDERS REVIEW: Capital result and good time for bonding
- RAIDERS REVIEW: We need to bring in a few quality players
- Texas talks throw up Barrow AFC transfer targets
- Barrow Raiders terror trio ready to be unleashed on Coventry
- County Matchplay Championship title first for Ulverston golfer
- Vets comp at Ulverston Golf Club a huge success
- Defending champions Furness back to winning ways
- Barrow Raiders unveil new youth plans (2 comments)
- Windermere win for Silecroft and Barrow trio
- Medal magic for Barrow martial arts masters
- Vital to pick up condition early
- South Cumbria children’s creativity worth crowing over
- Sharing the pain of chronic problem
- First Aid
- All aboard for a free trip into bus history
- Just rabbiting on about DIY skills
- Reply pleasing and surprising
- FOOD REVIEW: The Wheatsheaf Inn, Brigsteer (1 comment)
- From trenches to Dunkirk role