Free press is now a political football
Last updated at 12:43, Tuesday, 04 December 2012
IT should have been relatively simple – relatively being the operative word.
Crime and punishment usually is that way. You break the law, you’re named, shamed and you pay the price.When a gang of housebreakers is caught operating at night, the gang members are locked up. New law isn’t drawn up to keep the entire population indoors after dark.
So why then, when a handful of reporters are exposed as phone-hackers, sneak thieves, dupers, bribers and corrupters, should new law be introduced to deprive the entire population of its right to freedom of information?
Others with more intense political agendas and motivations will answer that. They’re doing so now, in a frenzied – bordering on hysterical – race to respond to Lord Justice Leveson’s report on press ethics.
There’s another operative word – ethics. Not criminality, because criminality should be dealt with by the police – and perhaps would have been had not some key police officers been involved in the criminality.
Culture and ethics was Lord Leveson’s brief, even though his inquiry was triggered by appalling and abhorrent crimes – exposed, incidentally, by disgusted journalists in an outraged free press.
The Leveson ball has been thrown into the politicians’ court now and this is where the grubby stuff really starts. The judge recommended beefed-up independent regulation of press culture, practices and ethics – underpinned by new law to hold the regulators to politically defined account.
My, how that set the usual salivating suspects into overdrive. David Cameron didn’t like it. Law would curb the press freedom this country has prized for more than 300 years, he said. New law wasn’t needed and would be loaded with danger.
Ed Miliband couldn’t wait to get his hands on it. He quite fancied a grip on the people’s mouthpiece. But as opposition leader, that’s his job. He opposes. And Nick Clegg, Cameron’s coalition partner, has manoeuvred himself into a predictable bargaining position for later, when the heat is on. You give me a bit of yours and I’ll give you some of mine. You scratch my back or I’ll stab yours.
Already we’re seeing how a free press – enshrined in Britain’s democracy for centuries – is being kicked around for political advantage. And they say we have nothing to fear?
First published at 12:42, Tuesday, 04 December 2012
Published by http://www.nwemail.co.uk
Have your say
I can sort of understand why the press are dissecting their own mis-deeds so closely but there are far bigger issues worth looking into such as smart metering water, power and gas and the governments latest attempt to 'come out' as the Stasi masquerading as May's 'think of the children' plea and the equally absurd 'our water supplies are under attack from unknown foreign countries' both of which are arguments she and her ilk are using to try and force their snooping charter on each and every one of us who makes a phone call or uses the internet in any way... shape... or form.Naturally there is the EU angle to both the smart meters and the internet overlord plan but that too is buried under a blizzard of stories about a very expensive report into naughty journalists.Free press?
Bad joke. There is clearly no such thing.
Make your comment
- Shock figures reveal the criminal offences taking place in South Cumbria schools
- Memory of Millom man lives on as £5k is raised for charity
- Fostering call made after shock figures revealed in Cumbria
- Campaigners change strategy in battle for Ulverston town centre’s soul (1 comment)
- Tayla-made campaign will keep life-saving on track
- Runners pound Dalton streets in 10k event
- ‘Selfless’ widower from Ulverston honoured for £78k fundraising effort
- South Cumbria rabbiting gang laugh after being fined for crimes
- Travel chaos looming in south Cumbria as rail union votes on strike
- Barrow teen avoids jail for drunken headbutt
- Barrow Raiders suffer defeat at North Wales
- CONFERENCE North’s sharpest shooters
- 'Barrow Raiders must beat away day blues'
- Six of the most important games in Barrow AFC's fight for the title
- Goal-hungry Barrow striker Andy Cook served up goals feast for fans
- Barrow Bluebirds captain Simon Grand dishes the dirt on his fellow players
- Barrow AFC sharpshooter Andy Cook picks out some extra special strikes
- It’s onwards and upwards says Barrow AFC's ambitious millionaire owner Paul Casson
- From Ormsgill in Barrow to Texas in America - Bluebirds owner's incredible journey
- New Barrow AFC shirt 'a good look' for next season says club's owner
- WEDDING ALBUM: Gill Frankland and Gavin Bartlett-Hurlstone
- Ideas led to building style and new jobs
- Find story of families
- Public Hall date for top recording stars
- Treasures seen in 3D
- WEDDING ALBUM: Dale Sheila Park and Simon Hobson
- FOOD REVIEW: Clarence House, Dalton
- Small trains at the station
- Did resurrection man become slave trader?
- I’m still having DIY flashbacks