Minister should have kept quiet over smacking
Last updated at 16:55, Tuesday, 05 February 2013
THERE are times when it’s wisest to shut up and say nowt – even when you’re bursting to have your say.
Justice secretary Chris Grayling should have known that before he whipped up a storm by defending parents’ rights to smack their children. Big mistake that. Huge.
The Tory cabinet minister said he was not opposed to smacking youngsters, claiming sometimes it “sends a message”.
Well, he certainly did that. Who’s sorry now?
Mr Grayling has two children, aged 20 and 16, and has admitted he occasionally smacked them when they were younger.
“You chastise children when they are bad, as my parents did me,” he said.
“I’m not opposed to smacking. It is to be used occasionally. Sometimes it sends a message – but I don’t hanker for the days when children were severely beaten at school.”
He was immediately condemned by children’s charities and lobby groups, who denounced his confessional as a charter for abuse behind closed doors. You can see their point.
You might well see his too.
But in these days of heavily policed thought and speech, it’s probably best not to say so.
In fact, the best idea would be to work out your own way of raising your children, find the most effective ways of chastising and disciplining and say as little as possible.
Because it’s bound to be wrong.
There is, of course, an enormous difference between beating the living daylights out of a child and slapping little fingers about to stray into an electric socket or unguarded fire.
Violence in the home, as was inflicted on poor tortured Baby P, compares in no way with an occasional smack that says: “For your own safety and for the safety of others, stop playing chicken on that busy road. Now!”
But if you don’t want to land yourself in hot water or be labelled a monster, don’t go there, even in polite conversation.
Smacking a child in anger translates into a dangerous loss of control and an absence of the patience required to reason with a youngster who needs to learn the difference between right and wrong.
Most parents understand that.
Chris Grayling isn’t alone in having been smacked as a child. He’s not the only parent to have slapped to “send a message”.
But he is a politician who really should know he’s on a hiding to nothing when he tries to talk about it sensibly.
First published at 16:46, Monday, 04 February 2013
Published by http://www.nwemail.co.uk
Have your say
Another politician who has to say sorry for speaking the truth about unruly children.
Disipline of a child,a parent should be allowed to disiplne his children,he has to control them.
Not some one sitting prone behind a desk in Brussels coming up with stupid ideas.
Disipline did not do me any harm.
I deserved,and took it with out question,when my dad handed it out.
Make your comment
- Cumbria mountaineer describes horrifying moment Nepal earthquake struck
- Cumbria man airlifted to hospital after ladder fall
- Signalling problems causing delays for Cumbria passengers
- Child's BMX bike stolen in Barrow
- Range Rover damaged in Broughton
- Cumbria runners set for London Marathon
- Millom Rugby Union Club awarded £10,000 grant (2 comments)
- Australian children send war tributes to South Cumbria
- Barrow attack victim: 'I was left for dead'
- Rescuers called out twice to missing walkers on Cumbria mountain
- Jubilant Barrow fans speak of joy and relief
- Barrow AFC crowned Conference North champions: with picture gallery (19 comments)
- Casson over the moon with Barrow AFC title success (6 comments)
- Edmondson hails title-winning Barrow AFC
- Barrow AFC fans ready for Lowestoft title decider:with picture gallery
- We give Barrow AFC fans the lowdown on Lowestoft
- Superfan’s 6,500 mile trip to see Barrow AFC
- Day of destiny for Barrow AFC
- Edmo calls on Barrow AFC to write club history
- AFC Fylde boss still believes his side can pip Barrow AFC to title
- Sea cadets prepare for their Big Clean
- Big Clean at Bardsea Beach
- Nation’s tribute for five flying heroes
- Mystery lady to sell at auction for £10k
- Winning village team could get 1,500 fans
- Selling the secrets of ship technology
- Classic cars set to return
- Why the speed trap claptrap?
- TRAVEL REVIEW: Tracing granddad Bert’s footsteps in ill-fated campaign
- FOOD REVIEW: The Plough, Lupton